Thought

Elon Musk is mad he’s been ordered to remove Sydney church stabbing videos from X. He’d be more furious if he saw our other laws

Retrieved on: 
Tuesday, April 23, 2024

Australia’s eSafety Commissioner has ordered social media platform “X” (formerly known as Twitter) to remove graphic videos of the stabbing of Bishop Mar Mari Emmanuel in Sydney last week from the site.

Key Points: 
  • Australia’s eSafety Commissioner has ordered social media platform “X” (formerly known as Twitter) to remove graphic videos of the stabbing of Bishop Mar Mari Emmanuel in Sydney last week from the site.
  • In response to this order, X’s owner, Elon Musk, has branded the commissioner the “Australian censorship commissar”.
  • Read more:
    Why is the Sydney church stabbing an act of terrorism, but the Bondi tragedy isn't?

Prompt political fallout

  • Labor minister Tanya Plibersek referred to Musk as an “egotistical billionaire”.
  • Of course such damning remarks directed towards a much-maligned website and its equally controversial owner are to be expected.

What do federal laws say?

  • The power she exercised under part nine of that act was to issue a “removal notice”.
  • The removal notice requires a social media platform to take down material that would be refused classification under the Classification Act.
  • While it’s these laws being applied in the case against X, there are other laws that can come into play.
  • It is a variation of this bill, reflecting the substantial range of views on the draft, that now has bipartisan support.

What else could be done?


Perhaps the gruesome images in the Wakeley videos might remind some of the Christchurch massacre. In that attack, Telstra, Optus, and Vodafone (now part of TPG), cut access to sites such as 4Chan, which were disseminating video of the attack. This was without any prompting from either the eSafety Commissioner or from law enforcement agencies.

  • She would need to be satisfied the material depicts abhorrent violent conduct and be satisfied the availability of the material online is likely to cause significant harm to the Australian community.
  • This means the commissioner could give a blocking notice to telcos which would have to block X for as long as the abhorrent material is available on the X platform.
  • This would be a breach of the terrorism prohibitions under the federal Criminal Code.


Rob Nicholls receives funding from the Australian Research Council for the International Digital Policy Observatory.

Parrot fever cases amid a ‘mysterious’ pneumonia outbreak in Argentina – what you need to know about psittacosis

Retrieved on: 
Tuesday, April 23, 2024

This is how the yet-to-be-named disease COVID-19 was first described when a cluster of cases was identified in Wuhan, China.

Key Points: 
  • This is how the yet-to-be-named disease COVID-19 was first described when a cluster of cases was identified in Wuhan, China.
  • This term is being used again to describe a cluster of “atypical” pneumonia cases in Buenos Aires, Argentina.
  • Some cases of psittacosis, also known as “parrot fever”, have been confirmed within this cluster.
  • Psittacosis, or parrot fever, is caused by bacteria called Chlamydia psittaci, and is a common infection in birds.
  • A 2017 systematic review concluded that around 1% of pneumonia cases not acquired in a hospital may be the result of psittacosis.
  • There are often local respiratory infectious disease outbreaks, potentially causing severe pneumonia, and these do not spread more widely or internationally.
  • At the time of writing this article, there is very little information available about the Argentina outbreak.
  • There has been no statement from the public health authorities in Argentina, nor the WHO Pan America Health Organisation.
  • Among the key pieces of information we really would need to know is the likelihood of human-to-human transmission.


Michael Head has previously received funding from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the UK Department for International Development, and currently receives funding from the UK Medical Research Foundation.

Vulture Capitalism: Grace Blakeley’s new book is smart on what has gone wrong since the 1980s

Retrieved on: 
Tuesday, April 23, 2024

The strength of Vulture Capitalism is in its powerful summary of developments over the past few decades.

Key Points: 
  • The strength of Vulture Capitalism is in its powerful summary of developments over the past few decades.
  • All these writers would presumably agree that the “neoliberal” policy approach adopted in the 1980s was a key inflection point towards today’s economic malaise.
  • Widening income inequality, declining social mobility and reduced life expectancies are further examples of this policy failure.
  • As examples she cites Amazon’s success at avoiding corporation tax, and Boeing’s change in management approach that prioritised profit maximisation over design safety.

The democratic deficit

  • Further to the idea of disempowered workers, Blakeley argues that the lack of democratic accountability in key domestic and international economic institutions helps to drive vulture capitalism.
  • They determine which businesses or individuals succeed, but ordinary people neither get told about these choices nor get any say in them.
  • These enable investors to take legal action against governments using their democratic prerogatives to tax, regulate and prosecute corporations.
  • Blakeley convincingly argues that this all adds up to a major democratic deficit in which “elite” classes operate without any accountability.

The way forward

  • Businesses choosing profits over safety and governments bailing out bosses while letting people starve do not represent a perversion of capitalism.
  • Several reach all the way back to the 1970s: trade unionists’ alternative plan to save ailing British firm Lucas Aerospace certainly demonstrated workers thinking strategically, but it was swatted aside by management.
  • Similarly, the more widespread attempts at democratic planning in Chile under Salvador Allende were crushed by Richard Nixon.
  • And if that worked effectively, there’s no reason why assemblies couldn’t be incorporated into, say, the negotiations around trade treaties.
  • Addressing the democratic deficit won’t solve everything, but it would be an important step in the right direction.


Conor O'Kane does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

The Anglican Communion has deep differences over homosexuality – but a process of dialogue, known as ‘via media,’ has helped hold contradictory beliefs together

Retrieved on: 
Tuesday, April 23, 2024

In the past six months, hundreds of congregations voted to leave the United Methodist Church over same-sex marriage and whether LGBTQ+ people should be clergy.

Key Points: 
  • In the past six months, hundreds of congregations voted to leave the United Methodist Church over same-sex marriage and whether LGBTQ+ people should be clergy.
  • With over 80 million believers in 160 countries, the Anglican Communion has been grappling with LGBTQ+ issues since the 1970s.
  • It is a long-standing process for navigating disputes called the “via media,” or middle way, which has thus far succeeded in holding together people with contradictory beliefs.

Controversies in the Anglican Communion

  • For decades, diverging points of view over homosexuality and rumors of schism have both confused and polarized believers in the global Anglican Communion.
  • This is part of a larger struggle within the Anglican Communion to renegotiate imbalances of power and authority left over from the colonial era of the British Empire.
  • In the 21st century, these churches still have most of the money in the Anglican Communion, but congregational numbers are dwindling.
  • That is the orthodox Anglican position.” Views like these carry great weight in the Anglican Communion, even today.
  • But they remain within the Anglican Communion.
  • The Episcopal Church in the U.S. has ordained openly gay bishops – most controversially Gene Robinson, former Bishop of New Hampshire, in 2003.
  • In 2016, the primates – the most senior leaders of the Anglican Communion – voted to suspend the Episcopal Church from decision-making on Anglican governance and policy for three years.

The via media

  • Despite such heated conflicts, the Anglican Communion holds together through the via media.
  • Via media was first mentioned by English reformers who broke from the Roman Catholic Church in the 16th century.
  • It is this Church of England that eventually spread globally with the British Empire to become the Anglican Communion.
  • In the 19th century, via media became a way of thinking about internal, rather than external, challenges, such as resolving debates over how to interpret scripture.

Holding together

  • It is this understanding of via media, I argue, that is holding the Anglican Communion together thus far.
  • Instead, it seeks to include people with deeply held but contrary beliefs within the same church through common worship and life.
  • The Church of England, for example, made plans for negotiations between people holding differing viewpoints before the Synod meets again in July 2024.


Lisa McClain is affiliated with her local Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Idaho. She is a professor of Gender Studies and a member of the international think tank The Inclusion Crowd as a gender expert.

Press release - “The Teachers’ Lounge” wins the LUX Audience Award 2024

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, April 18, 2024

“The Teachers’ Lounge” wins the LUX Audience Award 2024

Key Points: 
  • “The Teachers’ Lounge” wins the LUX Audience Award 2024
    “The Teachers’ Lounge” by German director Ilker Çatak won the 2024 LUX European Audience Film Award on Tuesday, in a ceremony in Parliament’s hemicycle in Brussels.
  • The film, produced in Germany, tells a story about Carla, a young high school teacher, distinguished from her colleagues by her idealism.
  • When a series of unsolved thefts sour the atmosphere among the teaching staff, Carla decides to investigate.
  • Press conference and related events
    You can watch the press conference with the winner Evelyn Regner and Mike Downey after the ceremony on EbS and EP Live.

Illmatic at 30: how Nas invented epistolary rap – and changed the hyper-masculine world of hip hop forever

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, April 18, 2024

At the time, these lines were seen as just another gem in a long line of highly sophisticated, literary Nas lyrics.

Key Points: 
  • At the time, these lines were seen as just another gem in a long line of highly sophisticated, literary Nas lyrics.
  • In many ways a verbal successor to Nas, Lamar controversially won an actual Pulitzer prize for music.
  • Like Lamar, Nas is as highly esteemed in the street as he is in academic circles.

One Love breaks new ground

  • The Illmatic track One Love (1994) introduced the “epistolary narrative”, or written letter technique, to the rap genre.
  • As journalist, educator and author Dax-Devlon Ross explains, One Love contains “a series of prison letters set to song”, which “effectively began the epistolary sub-genre” of rap.
  • Notable advocates of the technique include one-time rival of Nas, Tupac Shakur, releasing Dear Mama a year after One Love.

Illmatic’s legacy

  • Released two years after One Love, Xzibit utilised rap’s newly established epistolary sub-genre to pen an emotive open letter to his young son.
  • The Foundation addresses themes prevalent in the male African American experience, such as lineage, loyalty, masculinity and the paternal bond.

Nas today

  • In recent years, Nas has reached a purple patch of creativity, and released a flourish of well received albums, including both the King’s Disease (2020) and the Magic series.
  • When brought into the running of “top five dead or alive” rap debates, Nas is often quick to deflect from comparison, stating that there “ain’t no best”.
  • As Nas said himself in 2022: “I probably don’t need a therapist because I have music.” It’s hard to think of another rapper of his generation who has opened up so many doors for the artform.


Looking for something good? Cut through the noise with a carefully curated selection of the latest releases, live events and exhibitions, straight to your inbox every fortnight, on Fridays. Sign up here.
Paul Stephen Adey does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Why universities shouldn’t mark down international students for using non-standard English

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, April 18, 2024

This process has created not one English, spoken around the globe, but many Englishes.

Key Points: 
  • This process has created not one English, spoken around the globe, but many Englishes.
  • This has implications for universities that teach in English, and may have many non-native English speakers as students.
  • Universities and lecturers should consider what their approach should be to marking work written in non-native or non-standard varieties of English.

Hierarchies of English

  • For some, native speaker English is still seen as the “correct” variety, with native speakers seen as holding sole authority on how the language should be spoken.
  • Even within England, regional dialects may be seen as inferior to “standard” English.
  • In our current research, we focus on a specific world English – China English.
  • While based on standard English, China English has its own specific and identifiable use of grammar and vocabulary, which is predictable and systematic.
  • China English has its own expressions, such as “paper tiger”, meaning something that appears powerful but is in fact weak.
  • This predictability distinguishes China English from “Chinglish”, which refers to translation errors from a Chinese language (usually Mandarin) into English.


Nothing to disclose Alexander Baratta and Paul Vincent Smith do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Is this the dawn of a new era in women’s sports?

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, April 10, 2024

The women’s Final Four garnered higher television ratings than the men’s Final Four.

Key Points: 
  • The women’s Final Four garnered higher television ratings than the men’s Final Four.
  • And more than 90,000 fans attended the 1999 FIFA Women’s World Cup final in Pasadena, California.
  • Many fans, journalists and scholars are wondering if this is the dawn of a new era of women’s sports, with more coverage, increased viewership, heightened interest and bigger investments continuing in the future.

The long eclipse of women’s sports

  • We’re in the middle of collecting data for the eighth time, the results of which will be published in 2025.
  • Hundreds of studies on the routine coverage of sports have similarly found that media coverage of women’s sports rarely exceeds 10% of total sports coverage.
  • This is a recurring pattern across media platforms – print, TV, radio, social – in English-speaking countries.

Leapfrogging the gatekeepers

  • Podcasts like “Hear Her Sports,” “The Gist of It,” “Tea with A & Phee” and “Attacking Third” directly appeal to women’s sports fans.
  • They can simply directly engage with them on social media, producing and pushing content that bypasses traditional media gatekeepers.

Leveraging feminism

  • But my colleague Dunja Antunovic and I observed an important shift in sports media starting in the mid-2010s: the mobilization of feminism and principles of equality to promote and sell women’s sports.
  • In one chapter of our latest book, “Serving Equality: Feminism, Media, and Women’s Sports,” we focus on how women’s sports leagues and teams, as well as their corporate sponsors, have used the imagery, language and slogans of feminism and social justice movements to sell merchandise and tickets.
  • The video accompanying the campaign interspersed scenes of WNBA games with scenes from the 2017 Women’s March on Washington.

Being the change they want to see

  • While corporations and leagues deserve credit for highlighting the value of women’s sports, it’s also important to acknowledge how female athletes themselves have been driving change.
  • The activism of women athletes through the years has also created visibility for women’s sports.
  • In March 2019, the U.S. women’s national team players sued the U.S. Soccer Federation for gender discrimination.
  • Last year was the first year since the 1980s that the women’s tournament was broadcast on network television.


Cheryl Cooky has received funding and support from the Women's Sports Foundation. She consults on gender equality issues in sports and has partnered with Gatorade, Nike and Buick.

The Bank of Thailand reaffirms its adherence to integrity and principles to build confidence - good governance in Thailand

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, April 10, 2024

Anything we do or think, we have to be able to explain why we act or think this way," she noted.

Key Points: 
  • Anything we do or think, we have to be able to explain why we act or think this way," she noted.
  • The Bank of Thailand also vows to create transparency in the decision-making process and make it auditable.
  • The decision-making is transparent because there is a data storage and communication system so that it can always be traced back.
  • The NACC is supervised by the NACC Board and has the Office of the NACC as its administrative agency.